We get questions from customers every day about pool and spa products - their use, installation, maintenance, and so on. We're beginning a new feature here on the blog to help address some of the most frequently asked questions we receive. Today, we consider the issue of choosing the right sized heater for your particular needs.
People use their pools in differing patterns, particularly when the weather turns cool. Some prefer to set the water temperature to fall no lower than a specific minimum, which implies routine heater use (much like a thermostat regulates home heating). Others use the pool far less often in the cold weather months or only want to turn on their heater when necessary, such as preparing for a specific event.
No matter your usage preferences, there are four basic steps to take in order to determine heating requirements for all situations.
That temperature must be maintained, of course, but this can ordinarily be done with no more energy required than that used in the initial warmup phase.
- Calculate the volume of your pool in gallons. You probably
already have this information, but we can use a simple example to
illustrate the process:
Volume (in gallons) = Length (ft.) x Width (ft.) x Average depth x 7.5
the case of a rectangular pool that measures 20' by 30' with a
shallow-end depth of 4' and deep-end depth of 8', the calculation is
Volume = 20 x 30 x 6 x 7.5 = 27,000 gallons
This information is important because water volume dictates how
many BTUs will be needed for a specific pool. BTUs are a measurement
that represents the heat necessary to raise one pound of water one
degree Fahrenheit). Heaters, as you've probably noticed, are identified
partly by their BTU capacity per hour.
Determine how many BTUs will be needed to raise the temperature
throughout the pool one degree Fahrenheit. As we said BTUs are based on
pounds, and one gallon of water weighs 8.34 pounds, so the pool from the example above has
225,180 pounds of water.
27,000 gallons x 8.34 = 225,180 pounds of water
Find out how many BTUs are required to achieve a one-degree
temperature change within a 24-hour period. To do this you'll divide the
pool volume in pounds by 24.
225,180 / 24 = 9,382
- Now that you know how much heat is required to achieve one
degree of temperature change over 24 hours you can use that as a
multiplier, along with the number of degrees of desired temperature
increase, to determine how many BTUs are necessary for your pool to
reach the intended temperature in the 24-hour time frame.
For instance, if we want to raise our example pool's water temperature from 65*F to 85*F in 24 hours:
9.382 x 20 degrees = 187,680 BTUs will be needed, or 187K as commonly notated
Once you have a solid idea how long it will take to heat your own pool (based on its size and the capacity of available heating options) you're better equipped to shop around but there are other factors to consider. Let's compare a couple of popular heating options...
- Nearly 50% cheaper than comparable heat pump
- Heats pool quicker - Gas heaters burn either propane or natural gas inside a chamber that gets hotter faster
- Fairly simple to install
- Works better in cold climates
- Much lower energy bills - Only uses electricity
- More energy efficient
- Similar in operation to a home HVAC unit
- Longer life span (usually 10 years) - Due to the less volatile nature of the heat pump's internal processes (they draw heat from the air rather than creating it internally)
- Safer operation than gas heaters
- More costly to operate - Costs are tied to rising gas prices
- Less energy efficient - As much as 20% of the source gas doesn't burn completely
- The exhaust created by the burning process is harmful to the environment
- More likely to need repair - Equipment failure is typically an issue sooner than with heat pumps
- Shorter life span (usually 5 years)
- More expensive - Heat pumps are more complex than gas heaters, which helps explain the higher price tag
- Slower heat-up - Heat pumps draw outside (often very cold) air, then compresses it into gas which heats the circulating water
- Trouble with very cold climates
When it comes down to it, the gas heater (as the comparative BTUs suggest) will finish the job faster, and at less cost up front, but the heat pump is a more long-term approach, more likely to provide years of reliable service.
No matter which route makes more sense for you, It pays to treat your heating purchase as an investment. You will find that the jump in price from one size to the next (in both heaters and heat pumps) is not substantial in a relative sense. Going up a level or two in capacity from the minimum baseline you determined earlier won't greatly increase your energy consumption, either. A larger model, also, will require less time to perform the same amount of heating and thus be subject to less use.
Finally, it's important to remember that using additional methods to keep the pool warm (solar covers, solar panels, etc.) is another key way to place less strain on the heater itself, which can add years to its usefulness and provide a consistently comfortable pool. Check out one of our previous posts about additional heating methods for your pool.